An Interview with Roland Clark
Professor Roland Clark is a historian specializing in religion and politics in Romania after 1918, particularly the homegrown fascist movement known as the Iron Guard or the Legion of the Archangel Michael. From Australia, he studied History and Religious Studies as an undergraduate at Sydney University. After spending 18 months teaching at an American school in Brașov, Romania, in 2003-4, he pursued graduate study on Romanian Orthodox theologians Nichifor Crainic and Dumitru Stăniloae at the University of Pittsburgh in the United States, also translating Stăniloae’s The Holy Trinity: In the Beginning There Was Love (Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 2012). He now teaches at the School of Histories, Languages, and Cultures at the University of Liverpool in the UK.
Professor Clark has authored two monographs: Holy Legionary Youth: Fascist Activism in Interwar Romania (Cornell University Press, 2015) and Religious Reform and Sectarianism and Renewal in Interwar Romania: The Limits of Orthodoxy and Nation-Building (Bloomsbury Academic, 2021). In November 2024 the editor of the East-West Church Report met Professor Clark in Bebington, near Liverpool, for an illuminating overview of 20th-century links between Orthodoxy and fascism in Romania.
Could you briefly describe the appearance of fascism in Romania in the interwar years of the 20th century?
The interwar years saw rising fascism due to massive and widespread corruption. To start with, this was very much a grassroots movement of peasants and workers, but it spanned every social class—including the clergy. In 1938 King Carol II responded by establishing a royal dictatorship in place of democracy. As his prime minister, Patriarch Miron (Cristea)—the Romanian Orthodox Church’s first patriarch—introduced harsh anti-Semitic legislation. The move to a royal dictatorship was intended to curb the fascists: King Carol wanted to harness their growing popularity so that he, and not the people, would remain in control. However, his government collapsed at the beginning of the Second World War. Under Hitler’s pact with Stalin, Hungary was allowed to annex part of northern Transylvania, and the Soviet Union to annex northern Bukovina and Bessarabia. Romania could do nothing about this, and it was so humiliating for the royal dictatorship that the king was forced to step down. As Romanian troops withdrew from Bukovina and Bessarabia, they massacred local Jews, whom they blamed for what was happening.
In early September 1940, the Iron Guard—also called the Legion of Archangel Michael—came to power amid this political vacuum. They did so along with General Ion Antonescu, but their relations grew increasingly tense: The Legionaries stole whatever they could and reduced the country to anarchy, whereas Antonescu was a law-and-order sort of guy. The Legionaries rebelled against Antonescu in late January 1941: In the course of around four days of fighting between them and the army, a brutal pogrom took place in Bucharest. While small numbers were killed in comparison with later pogroms, it was grim: victims were hung on abattoir meat hooks and strung up in forests.
After this rebellion, Romania became a military dictatorship under Antonescu and a wartime ally of Hitler. It also carried out the Holocaust, with members of the Orthodox Church very much engaged as strong supporters of massacres of Jews and other minorities.
Given that the Iron Guard was also called the Legion of the Archangel Michael, were its founders inspired by Orthodox beliefs? Or did they just see the Orthodox Church as a useful political instrument?
The Guard’s founder, Corneliu Codreanu, was a politician from beginning to end. He was politically active even as a teenager, and his goal was anti-Semitism: “Let’s rid Romania of the Jews, and of corrupt politicians working with the Jews.” Codreanu’s mentor, Alexandru C. Cuza, was initially an outspoken atheist, but he became Orthodox when he saw its political value. Cuza rejected the Old Testament as the work of Jews, however: He began distributing pamphlets outside the gates of the Metropolitanate in Bucharest calling for the Old Testament to be removed from the Bible.
Codreanu was quite superstitious: He believed in lucky and unlucky days, and astrology. He drew on the tradition of the haiduc—a sort of Robin Hood or outlaw character in Romania—and dressed up in folk costumes. He wanted to be seen as a mystic, messianic sort of figure. In sum, his movement always had clear hallmarks of fascism—such as anti-Semitism—with Christian elements progressively introduced.
What was the response of the Romanian Orthodox Church?
Churches were in bed with fascists in countries across Europe during the 1930s. In Romania, however, the Orthodox Church officially declared its opposition, mostly because Patriarch Miron was allied with Liberal politicians initially. Codreanu consequently claimed that the Church had lost its way, and that his movement was obedient to the Church without agreeing with its position. At the same time, there were senior bishops openly attending fascist rallies, but in a personal capacity, as they did not have the official backing of the Church.
The Church’s leaders could not control what was happening?
Yes, and they also did not feel the need to do so. Clerics had been state employees since the late 19th century and were not allowed to get involved in politics. Essentially, the Church’s line was, “None of our priests are getting involved in politics, regardless of what it looks like.” (Grins.)
Was fascism in Romania an internal response to the local Jewish population or an attitude copied from Nazi Germany?
Anti-Semitism had been a core part of Romanian national identity since at least the 1840s, as people started to articulate the question, “What is Romanian-ness?” Large numbers of Jews lived in Bukovina and Bessarabia, which were part of the Pale of Settlement. Once incorporated into Greater Romania after 1918, this was where massacres and deportations of Jews took place. The state tried to establish power over those territories by “purifying” them as ethnically Romanian. Anti-Semitism was also worse in Bukovina and Bessarabia: Jews living in the Old Kingdom of Romania were persecuted, but they were not deported or massacred.
During the Second World War, Bukovina and Transnistria (the territory between the Dniester [Romanian: Nistru] and Bug rivers, today the breakaway Transnistria Republic and part of Ukraine) were also the locations of concentration camps. As Romanian forces advanced eastwards in July 1941, massacres took place in almost every village they reached, and they set up concentration camps after capturing the city of Odessa. Jews who survived previous massacres, as well as those from cities such as Iași and Suceava, were sent there, as were Roma and a few Evangelicals. While there were no gas chambers, the conditions were so horrific that inmates died of starvation, dysentery, typhus, and the like. According to official statistics, around 250,000 Jews and 25,000 Roma perished, but I have seen estimates of up to 400,000 Jews. Roma deaths are poorly documented—there may have been as few as 11,000, but there may also have been very many more.
The best book on the army’s motivation in all this is Grant Harward’s Romania’s Holy War: Soldiers, Motivation, and the Holocaust [Cornell University Press, 2021]. In great detail, he lays out the vast religious rhetoric and depths of anti-Semitism that permeated soldiers’ thinking. Their sense was that the campaign against Moscow was blessed by God for the destruction of atheistic Communism.
They were associating Jews with Communism in line with the common trope?
There are many speeches about “holy war” and the great things that Romanian troops are doing in the East. When Vice-Prime Minister Mihai Antonescu announced the June 1941 invasion of the USSR, he declared, “I believe that since the sacred wars of the Crusaders, not a battle was holier, greater, and more epic than that which Adolf Hitler, the apostle of our new civilization, began today.”1 Visiting war-torn Chișinău a few weeks later, the Orthodox priest Fr. Gheorghe Secaș wrote, “The Bolsheviks and the Jews have committed these acts of crude barbarity like true vandals. … The sons of Judah… are the children of the curse and they should receive double retribution for their barbaric deeds.”2
Were the atrocities committed by Romanian soldiers a continuation of those by the Legion?
The Legion was outlawed in January 1941, so there was no such thing as the Legion by the time the Holocaust began with Operation Barbarossa that summer. Consequently, the Legion is not accused of having carried out the Holocaust. However, while the general assumption is that they were all put in prison after the January 1941 rebellion, its members were still around.
Since the Securitate secret police archives are organized by name, I was able to go through hundreds of biographies of senior Legionaries to find out what they did after the rebellion. Many evaded prison entirely, while others were jailed for only a few months, meaning that most were free by July 1941. As their political past was tainted, they were no longer welcome in Romania. Many were conscripted, while others joined the army of their own accord. Their files just say things like: “Simion Lefter was in the 68th Infantry Regiment as a peacekeeper after the troops arrived in Odessa. On the Moldovan Front and the Western Front until the end of the war he served as company commander in the 15th Dorobanți Piatra Neamț Regiment with the rank of Lieutenant.” Knowing what the 68th Infantry Regiment was doing during those months, I was able to trace that individual’s movements around Europe and place him in villages where massacres took place. In this way, I have been able to show that former Legionaries were in the army at the times and places where there were massacres. I do not know if they were the ringleaders, but they were definitely there and involved, so it is no longer possible to say, “It was the army, not the Legion.” The army was full of Legionaries!
From 1944 onwards there was a reversal, as the Soviet Union began to win the war. Romania then turned Communist, which posed a huge problem for those Orthodox who were staunchly right-wing.
What happened to them?
Some went into monasteries in order to keep their heads down, but that did not work out because the Communists targeted specific monasteries for closure, such as the Vladimirești Monastery in 1956. Others kept quiet and reinvented themselves as Communists, while inwardly retaining their core fascist beliefs. Once Nicolae Ceaușescu came to power in 1965, he reinvented Romanian Communism as a nationalist form of Communism. This was perfect for the Orthodox Church: It could remain nationalist while supporting the Communist regime. However, the Church also became deeply infiltrated by the Securitate secret police under Communism to the extent that, if you went to confession, whatever you told your priest could be reported to the Securitate and result in your arrest.
Is this also clear from the Securitate archives?
Yes, it is very clear from those archives, and it has also become public knowledge. There were many exposés in the 1990s and 2000s, and people who were informers are still being exposed.
The Securitate archives appear to be extraordinarily open today.
When I was doing research in the past, there was no list of what files were available. If I wanted to see Codreanu’s file, for example, I had to give his name, date of birth, place of birth, and his parents’ first names. Without all of that information, you could not find someone’s file—you went in blind. Even with all the information needed to request a file, you could be told, “No, we don’t have any file on that person.” Then someone else might come in a week later and receive files for that person: Information was given to some people and not to others. Before providing a file, an archivist also had to read it and decide which bits were acceptable for researchers and which were not.
More recently, things have become much better. There are now finding aids and a proper list of which files are available, although I am still not convinced that it is comprehensive. In comparison with most of Eastern Europe, the Romanian files are breathtakingly open—but it is not a free-for-all.
How much was generally known under Communism about Romania’s involvement in the Holocaust, particularly that of the Orthodox Church?
Very little. Under Communism—and this is the case across Communist East-Central Europe—the Holocaust was not discussed. It was mentioned in terms of fascist crimes against humanity, but these were not seen as ethnic crimes. While the Holocaust was understood in the West in terms of racism and as directed against Jews, in the East it was framed as the bourgeoisie against workers. In Poland, for example, Polish and Jewish victims of the Holocaust were lumped together, so you had no sense of a separate attempt to wipe out the Jewish people. The same was true in Romania. There were a handful of trials for war crimes in the late 1940s, but they were not very detailed. No Church figure was ever asked about what they did in the East: They were seen as having served the Church and certainly not as having broken any rules. This was while there were priests writing approving articles in military and church newspapers, as well as visiting and blessing concentration camps. It is very well documented. Archimandrite Antim Nica, for example, was one of many priests involved in bribing officials to take home jewelry and goods he had stolen from Jews while in Transnistria, as well as being—like many other priests—implicated in the rape and sexual exploitation of Jewish women.3
Was this terrible legacy discovered with the collapse of Communism in 1989?
From 1990 people who were persecuted by the Communists became celebrated as true Romanian heroes, including right-wing nationalists such as Nichifor Crainic and Dumitru Stăniloae. Even fascism acquired a reasonably good name. Then, in the early 2000s, Holocaust history started to come through. The impetus for this came in June 2003, when Romania’s government shocked everyone by strongly emphasizing that no Holocaust took place within its boundaries between 1940 and 1945. In response to widespread pressure, the International Commission on the Holocaust in Romania was created to examine the issue. In 2004 its official report detailed Romania’s direct involvement in the Holocaust, including that of the Orthodox Church [see https://www.ushmm.org/m/pdfs/20080226-romania-commission-postwar.pdf.]
This history of the Holocaust was then mandated to be taught in schools, but none of the teachers knew about it, and it felt like a Western ideology being imposed upon Romanian education. Most Romanians still either do not understand that the Holocaust happened in Romania or do not believe that Romanians took part. General Antonescu is not seen as a genocidal maniac allied with Hitler; he is up there with Vlad Țepeș—Vlad the Impaler, or Dracula—as a tough but righteous king.
It is probably only within the past 10 years among specialists—and five years among the broader public—that people have started to realize what was involved. It is really only the work of historian Ionuț Biliuță over the past three or four years—very, very recent!—that has properly started to explain the role of the Church.
This summer the Romanian Orthodox Church listed 16 clerics approved for canonization in 2025 [https://basilica.ro/en/holy-synod-approves-canonization-of-16-modern-day-saints]. Dr. Biliuță subsequently maintained that half of them “either supported or expressed fascist and anti-Semitic ideas during the interwar years or following their imprisonment during Communism” [https://publicorthodoxy.org/2024/07/30/fascist-hagiographies]. What is your reaction to the names on the list?
None of them surprises me. The Church has been promising to do this for years saying, “We need to canonize these people,” but they have not done so precisely because of the problems and delicacies that it throws up. We have now reached a point where no one cares enough, and you can celebrate someone like Fr. Arsenie Boca, who has become a great miracle-working saint in Romania. Arsenie Boca was associated with the Legion—but under Antonescu’s regime and under Communism, when this sort of activism was illegal.
The really controversial one is Fr. Dumitru Stăniloae, just because he is so famous. When he came of age as a theologian in the mid-1930s, he was a disciple of the fascist theologian Nichifor Crainic. Crainic helped Stăniloae get published in his magazines, and Stăniloae defended Crainic in public. This was Stăniloae’s flirtation with fascism, but he did not join the Legion or any other fascist movement. At that time, he wrote anti-Semitic material and attacked Roman and Greek Catholics, but he later became famous for his ecumenicism through his involvement with the World Council of Churches in the 1960s. The Communist Romanian state did not permit someone to become involved in international affairs unless they were sure that person would do everything they were told to do. The secret police had Stăniloae under control by the time he was active in the WCC: They had kept him in prison long enough that he was “well-behaved” by the time he got out.
Ionut Biliuta’s recent article pointing out Stăniloae’s problematic past upset Rev. Dr. Radu Bordeianu, an Orthodox theologian at Duquesne University in Pittsburgh, who basically responded with, “Stăniloae may not have been pure, but he was still a good guy—we can use his ecumenicism” [https://publicorthodoxy.org/2024/08/27/st-dumitru-staniloae-complex-figure]. If you look at Stăniloae’s work during the 1930s though, his ecclesiology identifies Orthodoxy with the Romanian nation. Contemporary Orthodox theologians like John Zizioulas and Nicholas Afanasiev, by contrast, shared a eucharistic ecclesiology. Once Stăniloae articulates his ecclesiology again in the 1960s, it is based upon “open sobornicity”—“my group is friends with your group”—which still assumes that churches are collectivities based on ties such as nationality, kinship, or territory, and that churches relate to each other in much the same way as nations do. In a sense, his “open sobornicity” of the 1960s is the same way of thinking about the church that he promoted in the 1930s, just without using the word “nation” anymore. To my mind, that is why Stăniloae is problematic [https://publicorthodoxy.org/2024/10/02/nationalism-and-ecumenicism].
Overall, I think the list is pretty clean compared with what was possible. There is a strong grassroots movement in Romania to canonize Codreanu, for example, as well as two of the Iron Guard’s martyrs from the 1930s, Ion Moța and Vasile Marin. I do not think that will ever happen, though—it would be like canonizing Hitler.
[Editor’s note: An official Romanian Patriarchate statement on 17 July 2024 acknowledged that some Orthodox saints displayed “at certain moments in their lives, attitudes and actions that are difficult to understand or even contrary to Christian teaching. However, the Church takes into account change in a sinner’s life, especially the way in which they ended their life, without encouraging (sanctifying) certain deviations by those persons during their lives” https://basilica.ro/comunicat-punct-de-vedere-canonizari-recente-ale-sfantului-sinod-al-bisericii-ortodoxe-romane.]
Is the difficulty of gauging both the depth and duration of fascist ties a challenge? The reality appears to have been complex: Fr. Nicolae Steinhardt, an ethnic Jew, was imprisoned in 1959 because he refused to testify against a former Legionary journalist, for example.
He was in prison as a converted Jew, but he made friends with Legionaries in prison. Many of those on this list are being canonized because they were persecuted in Communist prisons. Why did they end up in prison? Because they were Legionaries—but many of them were not in fact Legionaries. Just because you went to prison as a Legionary does not mean that you actually were one. This was a label that the Communists often threw at anyone they didn’t like, so it is a very complex situation. Also, there were different types of Legionaries in prison. A small minority became Christian mystics while they were there, and they were mocked and persecuted by the other Legionaries.
In the late 1940s and early 1950s, a lot of young people wanted to become anti-Communists, but they needed some sort of ideology to draw them together. They looked back at the Legion, read some of Codreanu’s writings, and thought, “Wow, this guy was a saint and a mystic! We want to be like that!” But they had not known Codreanu—the eldest were young children in the 1930s. The Communists immediately threw them into prison as Legionaries, where they met actual Legionaries for the first time. Those Legionaries mentored them, but the problem there is that three people would frequently be placed in a cell together, one being an informer who would encourage the others to talk about their past: “Do you remember when we did this?” The Communists would record that conversation and use it as evidence against the other two—but, knowing they were being recorded, they would lie to each other. We consequently have reams of archival documents of people in prison telling stories to each other about their Legionary past—but we have no idea if any of it is true.
There were also Legionaries in exile presenting themselves as anti-Communists, who played up elements of religion and martyrdom in Communist prisons. They ignored all the anti-Semitism of the 1930s and rewrote that history in the 1960s to make the Legion look more mystical and religious than it really was—if you look only at sources from the ’30s, you do not see it.
Looking at the list of proposed canonizations, are there any names obviously missing?
There is almost no one from the Burning Bush [Romanian: Rugul Aprins] movement, such as Daniil (Sandu) Tudor. There is no one important from before 1945, such as the theologian Gala Galaction, who was a left-wing theologian. Other interesting people who are not there are Metropolitan Antonie Plămădeală and Metropolitan Bartolomeu Anania. If you are going to consider the most important Romanian Orthodox figures of the 20th century, they are both giants, yet they are completely ignored—I think partly because they have clearly problematic pasts, but also because they worked too closely with the Communists. The selection of these particular saints is partly an attempt to make it look like the Church suffered under Communism, when in reality it was deeply implicated in the Communist state. These people were the exceptions, not the rule.
Notes:
1 Quoted in Grant Hayward, Romania’s Holy War: Soldiers, Motivation, and the Holocaust (Cornell University Press, 2021), 92.
2 Quoted in Ionuț Biliuță, “‘Christianizing” Transnistria: Romanian Orthodox Clergy as Beneficiaries, Perpetrators, and Rescuers during the Holocaust,” Holocaust and Genocide Studies 34, no. 1 (2020), 24.
3 Ibid., 28-31.