An Interview with Fr. Pantelimon Mocan
In late November 2023 the editor of the East-West Church Report visited Nicula Monastery, some 30 miles northeast of the Transylvanian city of Cluj. There, one of the resident monks, Pantelimon Mocan, outlined the monastery’s 500-year history, including its 18th-century transfer to Romania’s Greek Catholic Church, which recognizes the Pope of Rome while generally following Orthodox rites. With the installation of a Communist regime following the Second World War, the Greek Catholic Church in Romania was outlawed. At Nicula, its monks were imprisoned, and the monastery was transferred back to the Romanian Orthodox Church. The editor of the Report briefly asked Fr. Pantelimon how the monastery had fared under Communism and more recently. Local translator Codruța Popovici assisted by interpreting to and from Romanian.
What was the situation for Nicula Monastery after it was transferred to the Orthodox Church in 1948?
Patriarch Justinian (Marina, d.1977) knew how to deal with the Communist regime. He worked to enrich the Orthodox Church with more monasteries and monks, until the Communists figured out what had happened! (Laughs.) They viewed this increase as a danger. In 1959 they passed a decree prohibiting all monks and nuns younger than a certain age. Younger ones were forced to leave—to work in factories or to get married—and monasteries became empty and few. [Editor’s note: Decree 410 of 19 November 1959 stipulated that monks must be at least 55 years old and nuns 50 years old, leading to the eviction of approximately 5,000 monks and nuns.] People who wished to enter monasteries were no longer admitted—that was the case until the 1989 Revolution. There was then an explosion of enthusiasm in the 1990s, and the monasteries were filled again.
Why do you think such an explosion occurred in Romania?
The same phenomenon happened elsewhere—the Russian Orthodox Church experienced this wave as well.
Proportionate to size of population, though, there are roughly four times as many Orthodox monasteries in Romania as in Russia.
As a country, we were helped by our proximity to Greece—its culture and spirituality. The Greeks managed to keep their Orthodox tradition, especially on the holy mountain of Mount Athos. We somehow found our balance through them. At present we are discovering Byzantine culture more and more: sacred music—especially the Psalter, church architecture, and spirituality. We like to see and know the holy places—many Romanian Orthodox pilgrims have visited Jerusalem, Mount Athos, and other parts of Greece. When people come back, they are spiritually richer.
How many monks are here at Nicula Monastery currently?
There are 15 monks plus an additional two nuns—fewer than we used to be. In the 1990s we were more than 40, but the others were transferred to newer monasteries. Monastic vocations are also declining.
Are there any particular reasons in Romania for that drop?
That is a very long story. Mass media has an important part to play; the Church is under attack even now, and young people have various ways to separate themselves from the Church—or to be separated from the Church, voluntarily or involuntarily. Yet God performs His own works in Romania, and even now we have young people who come with a calling or vocation. We have experienced fluctuations, just like on Mount Athos. Mount Athos almost emptied in the 19th century, but experienced an invigorating phenomenon in the 20th.
Nicula Monastery has been an important pilgrimage center since the early 17th century. To what extent were pilgrims able to visit during the Communist period?
I just published a book containing documents from that era about six elder monks [Romanian: stareții] at Nicula during that time. In the early years of the regime, 1948-50, the Communists tried to stop pilgrims from coming here. How did they do this? Around 15th August, a holy day for the monastery [Editor’s note: The feast of the Dormition of the Mother of God according to the Gregorian calendar], they spread the news that a new disease—paralysis affecting infants—had appeared, for example. Many people were scared they might catch it and thought it would be better not to go to the monastery. Along the approach roads, police officers would also stop people who still wanted to go from making the journey. In those years, only a couple of hundred pilgrims managed to come. Later on, pilgrims came in greater numbers—two or three thousand, then seven or eight thousand: The numbers grew every year, even during the Communist era. Today thousands of people come, typically walking more than 60 miles over two days. They attend worship services, including late at night. It is like being in heaven!