An Interview with Andrei Dîrlău
Andrei Dîrlău is a senator in Romania’s parliament representing the Alliance for the Union of Romanians [Romanian: Alianța pentru Unirea Românilor], a right-wing political party whose candidate placed second or close third in recent opinion polls for Romania’s 24 November presidential election. A dedicated Orthodox Christian, graduate of the University of Bucharest, and professional interpreter, Andrei is also author of a novella, The Book of Things Unknown. Published in English in 2020, its narrator recounts how an intricate interplay of life encounters and literary exploration led to the maturation of his personal faith.
The editor of the East-West Church Report met Andrei in late November 2023 in the offices of the Romanian Senate, part of the grandiose Palace of the Parliament in downtown Bucharest. The construction of this immense building in the 1980s—a walk across the front façade takes approximately 10 minutes—was ordered by Communist dictator Nicolae Ceaușescu and entailed the destruction of multiple historical churches. Today, the gleaming gilded domes and white walls of a towering new edifice under construction are visible from Andrei’s office window: the People’s Redemption National Cathedral of the Ascension and St. Andrew, the tallest Orthodox church in the world.
The editor’s interview with Andrei Dîrlău took place in English.
What is your background?
I was born and have lived all my life here in Bucharest. After military service, I first studied economics and international relations, graduating in 1980. I then took a second degree in foreign languages and literatures: English, Spanish, and French. My dissertation was on the Romanian Romantic poet Mihai Eminescu and the English Romantic poet William Blake. After this second degree, Fr. Constantin Galeriu—an Orthodox priest and professor of theology I met in 1987—urged me to study theology. I said, “I don’t need another degree!” but he countered: “You are not an educated and cultivated person if you don’t know theology.” So I did a Master’s and a PhD in theology—the history of religions. Fr. Galeriu was right: Theology gives one a better perspective on cultural issues.
It was providential that I met Fr. Galeriu. He was a very well-known parish priest at St. Sylvester Church here in Bucharest. He would deliver extraordinarily powerful sermons. They might last an hour or more, but nobody left the church. He was erudite—he could quote the Patristic Fathers of the Church by heart—but he also had a gift of being able to present Christian doctrine in a way that everyone could understand, whether very simple people or highbrow intellectuals. People came to him because he loved everyone, and he embraced everyone with the same love. He never said anything like, “You are an atheist, you will go to hell!” He never judged anyone for their beliefs, whether a freemason, yogi, or believer in reincarnation. In Bucharest thousands of people were converted like this in the 1980s.
Did Fr. Galeriu’s sermons have any particular themes?
He believed very much in the unity of the Church, and he very much wanted to see a unity of the Christian churches. Here I have to be very clear: Fr. Galeriu—along with our Romanian Orthodox Church—rejected ecumenism when understood as a kind of compromise from a dogmatic point of view. He stuck to the doctrine of the Patristic Fathers of the first millennium—St. John Chrysostom, St. Basil the Great, St. Gregory of Nyssa, St. Gregory of Nazianzus, St. Maximus the Confessor… there are so many!—who laid the foundation of Christian theology completely in accordance with the Gospel.
This is the heritage that we keep. The Orthodox Church is organized along national lines, and we are accused sometimes of phyletism—emphasizing the ethnic or national component to the detriment of the universality of the teaching of Christ. I say this because it is important to understand the distinction between the national identity element within the Orthodox tradition in Romania or Russia, for example, and the universal or ecumenical nature of the teaching of Christ—oikoumene meaning “world” in Greek. Fr. Galeriu was ecumenical from this point of view; embracing everyone in a universal embrace. He said that every human being is made in the image and likeness of God, and God is love.
That is another fundamental idea that he always insisted upon: “If God is love and we are made in His image, then this means that the definition of man—of human beings—is also love.” This is man’s essence, and we should strive at being love, full of love in the image and likeness of God, because that is our deepest identity. This has been obscured by layers of sin, passions, and dark elements, so that we find it difficult to love. But we should try to reach the deep level in ourselves where we can find this essential feature of love, God in us. We should dedicate all our lives to attaining this love, and so sainthood: Once you reach that level, that is what saints are. They are nothing but human beings who have cultivated this image of God in themselves and so become deified by grace. Not deified ontologically—man can never become God—but by being in the image and likeness of God. The image is something you have already, while the likeness is something you should strive to obtain. These two dimensions were Fr. Galeriu’s major teaching.
How did the atmosphere at Fr. Galeriu’s church in the late 1980s contrast with the rest of society under the Communist regime of Nicolae Ceaușescu?
In terms of demolished churches, things never got as bad in Romania as in the Soviet Union. But after 1947 [the establishment of Communist rule]—in the 1950s until 1964—very many thousands of people, mostly Christians, were killed by the Communist authorities, the Securitate secret police. Things became a little less violent after 1964.
Was there a shift in the regime, as in the Soviet Union after the removal of Nikita Khrushchev?
In the early ’60s Romania got rid of almost all Soviet influence. Soviet troops were kicked out of the country, so it was better from that point of view. As the regime also felt safe and consolidated, they were no longer afraid of any threat from the Church. All the “enemies of the state” had been killed, imprisoned, or silenced. So they relaxed the tension a little, particularly in the ’70s: Romania had opposed the 1968 [Soviet-led] invasion of Czechoslovakia very vocally, and was viewed rather favorably by the West because of this semi-dissident position within the Eastern Bloc.
In the 1980s things worsened a little, but churches were still open. If one had a certain position—in the Communist Party, the army, the Securitate, or a government ministry—it was not a good idea to go to church. However, many other people went—the churches were rather full. Priests could hold services and deliver sermons, but it was not permitted to go out and preach, or to have any form of mission in society. You could not find Bibles or any Christian literature in bookshops.
Did you need any special permission to access that type of literature in public libraries?
No, but you had to know exactly what to search for. Of course, Fr. Galeriu had his own large library. The Romanian Orthodox Church even published translations of patristic writings in those years. That was only for internal circulation, however.
My point here is that Christianity was permitted, and that Fr. Galeriu was allowed to preach, just not outside church. He could deliver university lectures as a theology professor—he taught dogmatics and homiletics—but he was not allowed on television or to preach in the public square. Priests and theologians had to stay within their own quarters, in a church or a monastery. So people came to them! In those years I visited many monasteries and met elder monks like Fr. Cleopa Ilie, who was Fr. Galeriu’s spiritual father—there were scores of them across Romania. The tradition of these monastic elders was very important: They upheld the faith in Communist times more than anybody else. They were the main focus, the main resistance. Fr. Galeriu was imprisoned, as were many others. After they were released, they saw faith as a matter of life and death, not [assumes lukewarm tone] “Okay, I’m a Christian.”
Why was Fr. Galeriu imprisoned?
Because he openly opposed Communism. He did not oppose the regime in a political way like Fr. Gheorghe Calciu [a prominent priest who criticized the regime in sermons aimed at young people, and who was imprisoned repeatedly before being exiled to the West in 1985.] Fr. Galeriu just upheld Christianity. Yet that was enough, because there is clearly an incompatibility between Christian and Communist doctrine, which is atheistic and materialistic.
These elders incarnated a living tradition. Orthodoxy relies very much upon elder-to-disciple transmission—personal transmission of faith that has continued for two thousand years. It continues today in Romania, only not at the same level, because these people were saints. I will tell one story. Back in 1988, my father—then in his mid-seventies—lay dying from asthma in hospital. The doctors said, “We can’t do anything. Take him home so that his death won’t be on our records.” When my mother and I took my father home, he was suffocating—his medicine no longer had any effect. Someone suggested that we go to one of these great elders, Fr. Ilarion Argatu in Cernica Monastery near Bucharest, so my mother and I took my father there in a taxi. Fr. Argatu’s small monastic cell was packed with people, and we brought my father to him on a bed, as he couldn’t stand up. Fr. Argatu uttered prayers of exorcism for all the people present in the room. Then he touched my father on his forehead and said a prayer. My father left walking by himself. He lived more than seven years after that, in relatively good health.
Fr. Argatu was a saint, as was Fr. Galeriu. On meeting them, this was unmistakable—you could not help but perceive the presence of Divine grace. I also visited Fr. Arsenie Papacioc, an elder who lived at a monastery in Techirghiol, near the Black Sea. In the morning, he got up, put on his cassock and boots, and said: “I’m a soldier of God!” He spent the whole day in worship services and talking to people about their burdens. This was his mission. When you talked to him, you could not help but be converted. He transmitted Church tradition in a living, personal way. Such elders converted millions of people—I say this without hesitation.
[Editor’s note: On 12 July 2024 the Romanian Orthodox Church approved the canonization of 16 Communist-era saints, including Archimandrite Cleopa Ilie and renowned theologian Fr. Dumitru Stăniloae: https://basilica.ro/en/holy-synod-approves-canonization-of-16-modern-day-saints/.]
To what extent did the Communist regime subvert the Romanian Orthodox Church through collaboration?
Nobody really knows. There were certainly some hierarchs and priests who collaborated with the Securitate, but how far it went is really open to question. It’s not black and white. Sometimes a compromise could be necessary for the greater good of the Church. Here, I am not trying to be apologetic or absolve guilt; I am just trying to have discernment and to understand things as they were. For example, a patriarch might form an alliance with the regime because he was incapable of doing anything else, but on the other hand, he saved other things. Churches were open the whole time in Romania. Monasteries were closed for a short while, but then re-opened—there were thousands of monks and nuns. Priests received training, and several universities had theological departments. In the ’70s, Fr. Galeriu was able to publish his PhD thesis, and Fr. Dumitru Stăniloae was able to work and publish in Romania during the 30 years after his release from prison in 1963. [Editor’s note: The next issue of the East-West Church Report will delve further into the impact of Communist—and fascist—regimes upon Christianity in Romania.]
Did you also study theology under the Communist regime?
No. I began my third degree—in theology—after the so-called Revolution we had here in 1989.
Was there a sense that year that something was going to happen, a build-up of popular resentment?
It was not a national uprising, but a geopolitical decision due to a change in the balance of power. The United States had won [the Cold War] economically and militarily—the Soviet Union was not able to keep up. [Then Soviet leader Mikhail] Gorbachev was faced with a choice: either complete collapse or save something by imposing glasnost’ [Russian: transparency, openness] as a kind of “socialism with a human face.” However, that did not and could not work, because Communism cannot exist unless it is a dictatorship. So, as Communism collapsed in the Soviet Union, it collapsed all over Eastern Europe. There was no way it could survive in just one country.
In Romania we had a distant sense that this process was happening—people listened to Radio Free Europe and Voice of America—so it was not something unexpected. But it was hard to believe, and the way it happened here was very violent. [Editor’s note: Thousands of people were killed and wounded when the authorities attempted to suppress street protests that began as Nicolae Ceaușescu was addressing a large crowd in Bucharest. He and his wife were swiftly overthrown, tried, and executed on 25 December.] Somehow, the other dictators realized what was going on and yielded. Ceaușescu did not do that. He thought that he could save himself and the regime; he was living in a kind of bubble, perhaps. His advisers did not tell him—many have said that he was sabotaged by his own security services, who did not tell him the truth.
They saw that he would not understand the situation?
They wanted him to become a scapegoat. Their thinking was along these lines: “It [the collapse of Communism] will happen. Let’s save ourselves. But we have to blame someone— Ceaușescu is the perfect scapegoat.” And that is what happened—the whole system got away; all the high-ranking Communist Party members, the activists—there were only a few exceptions who went to jail. The system, with all its privileges, survived—officials were able to buy their government villas legally for a low price, for example. They turned the system around to their own benefit.
Did you witness the violent events of December 1989?
I went out in the streets on the 21st. I was in the crowd—I was 33 in 1989, old enough to understand what was going on. I was arrested not far from the square where Ceaușescu was making his speech. I was put into a police van with about 10 others. We were unsure what was happening—at first we thought they were going to take us into the forest outside Bucharest and shoot us; that we would simply disappear. We were relieved when someone finally opened the doors and said that we had reached Jilava Prison! I was held there until noon the next day, packed with around 70 people into a cell with beds for only 20. Thousands of people were there.
So I was in the Revolution! (Chuckles.) I believed things would change. Things have changed—some for better, some for worse. For better is the fact that I have a passport—we are free to travel anywhere. We joined the European Union in 2007, NATO in 2004. [Editor’s note: According to the Pew Research Center’s landmark 2017 study, “Religious Belief and National Belonging in Central and Eastern Europe,” 82 percent of Romanians—by far the largest figure in any Orthodox majority nation polled—agreed that it was in their country’s interest to work closely with the USA and other Western powers. In Ukraine at that time, this figure was 62 percent: www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/05/10/religious-belief-and-national-belonging-in-central-and-eastern-europe.] We have democracy. We can have Christian mission openly—Christianity is not persecuted or simply tolerated, but even promoted.
However, there are many pressures and threats to Christianity from secularization imported from the West: LGBT, political correctness, neo-Marxism. For youngsters it is not so easy to resist these tendencies—this is the cultural environment in which they grow up. In school they might have one hour of religion a week, taught by a teacher with more or less grace or tact and pedagogical talent, but there are examples of teachers with less talent who can have the effect of turning pupils away.
Such imposition of religion contributed to the rapid secularization of the West.
The West has undergone a serious transformation. Today it is more secular and exporting anti-Christian attitudes and philosophy. Paradoxically, the West meant Christianity in the 1970s and ’80s, when I was young.
Claiming to be Christian may still feature in today’s Western political discourse as a superficial pitch for votes.
Yes, it went down from a spiritual teaching to a civic attitude—activism and social justice, which is still good—and is now degrading simply to political propaganda. So, the road from real faith to civic attitude to ideology is the road to secularization.
Is Romanian society more spiritually robust, given the resilience of Orthodoxy under Communism that you have described, as well as the huge increase in popular engagement with the Church following 1989?
Following 1989 there was great enthusiasm for the Church because it became free after being barely tolerated. There was a renaissance of Christian life, including a great surge in monastic life. Today we are witnessing the opposite—if that was a flow, now we have an ebb of monastic vocations. In Romania we have about 7,000 monks and nuns in about 600 monasteries and convents. That is a lot, but we now see monasteries with only two or three monks or nuns, and not 20 or 40, as there used to be. This is a little worrying, as monastic vocations are not something that you can take for granted.
Might Romania’s entry into the European Union in 2007 yet contribute to the spiritual revitalization of Western Europe? Some émigré Romanian Orthodox communities there are large and active.
I trust God works in mysterious ways. Maybe God is working through something we consider a tragedy—because for us it is a tragedy that some six million have left the country even though we have no war, and there have also been many millions of abortions since 1989. [According to the Pew Research Center’s 2017 study “Religious Belief and National Belonging in Central and Eastern Europe,” 58 percent of Romanians agreed that abortion should be legal in all or most cases: www.pewresearch.org/religion/2017/05/10/religious-belief-and-national-belonging-in-central-and-eastern-europe.] Abortion is used as a form of contraceptive not only for economic reasons, but also due to a lack of morality and education. I’m sorry to say that such problems are the other side of an Orthodox society—I don’t want to lie and present everything as rosy.
What does it mean, to be a Christian? In the watered-down understanding of Christianity now prevalent in the West, it means to be a nice person, to behave nicely towards your fellow human beings. This is a memory of a Christian tradition that has all but disappeared, but it is still valuable. What do you think people will answer here in Romania, if you ask them what it means to be Christian, to be Orthodox? Their answer will be: to go to church. Going to church is one thing: “I believe in God—I pray.” That is good and valuable, but it is only one aspect. There is a discrepancy I observe in Romanian society. A person might go to church yet despise their fellow human beings once they leave. This might not be in an aggressive way—they are just selfish and don’t care. I love the Orthodox tradition, and the elders I have described certainly never preached anything else. But we are weak at kindness and love, which makes it difficult for us to behave up to the standard. We know that we have to love our enemies, but we can barely love our neighbors!
How do Romanian Orthodox generally view the Republic of Moldova, which was Romanian territory between the two World Wars?
Moldova is regarded by us as part of Romania. We hope to be reunited. This is very difficult for geopolitical reasons—Moldova is not in NATO or the EU. While no longer part of the Soviet Union, it is still in Russia’s sphere of influence. In 1990 the Romanian Church re-established a metropolitanate in [newly independent] Moldova—-the Metropolis of Bessarabia. There is now competition between our metropolitanate and the Metropolis of Chișinău and All Moldova, which is under the jurisdiction of Moscow. I estimate that around one third of Moldovan parishes are now under our jurisdiction—they are transferring slowly, as we want this to be a free choice of each respective parish community. However, Moscow promotes fierce propaganda, saying: “Don’t leave, because if you go to the Romanian Church, they are in the European Union! You will become LGBT-icized! You will have gay bishops! You will have women bishops and priests! Stay with us, because we are the stronghold of Orthodoxy.” [See also Andrew Higgins, “‘Sinners’ and ‘Russian Talibans’: A Holy War Roils a Once Placid Village, New York Times, 17 July 2024, https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/17/world/europe/russian-orthodox-church-ukraine-war-moldova.html.]
The Russians are serious, no doubt—they have great saints, such as St. Seraphim of Sarov. Some say we should be with Russia—there are people here who say that. Others say life would become totalitarian because Putin has a totalitarian regime. Do we want that?
Is there a linguistic distinction between the two metropolitanates in Moldova?
No, even Moscow’s metropolitanate has services in Romanian. For a long time after breaking with the Soviet Union, the Chișinău authorities claimed the population spoke the Moldovan language, not Romanian, but there is almost no difference. What is spoken in Moldova is perhaps a dialect. Now, at last, Romanian is the official language of Moldova. [See “Moldovan parliament approves law on Romanian language, Reuters, 16 March 2023, www.reuters.com/world/europe/moldovan-parliament-approves-law-romanian-language-2023-03-16.] In Moldova they do follow the Old Style church calendar, but they may keep that—we are not forcing them to switch.
We are also trying to set up a Romanian metropolitanate in Ukraine. In regions such as Budjak [the territory between the Republic of Moldova and the Black Sea], which also used to belong to Romania, there are around half a million Romanian speakers. [Editor’s note: on 29 February 2024 the Holy Synod of the Romanian Orthodox Church established a structure called the Romanian Orthodox Church in Ukraine: https://basilica.ro/en/romanian-orthodox-church-holy-synod-meets-for-first-time-this-year-main-decisions.]
Soon after Russian forces invaded Ukraine in February 2022, a spokesperson for the Romanian Orthodox Church issued a critical statement. This described the war as “caused by a political pathology, by a clinical imperialist vision, and, outrageously, blessed, even implicitly, by someone who, totally lacking in moral acuity, has identified the ‘forces of evil’ exactly where they are lacking, thus cleverly, but utterly dishonorably, substituting the aggressor for the victim.” [Editor’s note: Issued on 5 March 2022, the statement was quickly removed from the Church’s website. An English translation remains at: https://orthodoxtimes.com/patriarchate-of-romania-this-war-is-caused-by-a-clinical-imperialist-vision-and-blessed-by-someone-who-lacks-in-moral-acuity.]
So he was blaming Russia, right?
The statement does not name Patriarch Kirill, but it appears to blame the Moscow Patriarchate for backing the invasion.
Well, that’s true—they blessed the tanks.
Does this suggest that the Romanian Patriarchate has taken sides in the rivalry of the Orthodox Patriarchates of Moscow and Constantinople over Ukraine?
Our Patriarch Daniel is too smart to do that. He does not want to be on very bad terms with Moscow, but he cannot side with them either. He has perfectly good relations with Bartholomew [Patriarch of Constantinople, Orthodoxy’s most senior hierarch], who came to consecrate the cathedral over there [indicating the People’s Redemption National Cathedral of the Ascension and St. Andrew through the Senate windows] in 2018. Our patriarch is trying to maintain a balance.
In this situation, we care about the interests of the Romanian Church, the Romanian people, and the Romanians in Ukraine and Moldova. We also care about the cause of Orthodoxy, because in the future we would like to see unity that is truly pan-Orthodox.