An Interview with Fr. Professor Ioan Chirilă

Fr. Ioan Chirilă is a Romanian Orthodox priest and theology professor at Babeș-Bolyai University in Cluj (officially Cluj-Napoca), the largest city in the Transylvania region of northwestern Romania. He was successively chancellor and dean of the university’s Faculty of Orthodox Theology (1997-2012). During the two terms he subsequently served as president of the university’s Senate (2012-2020), he welcomed various international visitors, including the future King Charles III of the United Kingdom, who was awarded an honoris causa doctorate by Babeș-Bolyai University in 2017.

Locally, Fr. Ioan Chirilă is also renowned as a poet. In late November 2023 he delivered a sermon to a packed Orthodox parish church in suburban Cluj to mark the occasion of its patronal feast: the Entry of the Mother of God into the Temple. Thanks to simultaneous translation by Codruţa Popovici, the editor of the East-West Church Report heard Fr. Ioan weave poetic imagery from Romanian folk carols depicting snow-covered ground and subsequent spring seedlings with reflections on the pure offerings to God made by the Virgin Mary—herself—and the myrrh-bearing women who approached Christ’s tomb on Easter morning as examples of being “rich toward God.” In this way, he tied together the day’s assigned readings from Mark 16, Ephesians 2, and Luke 12 with folklore symbolism familiar to all parishioners.

 A few days prior, the editor of the East-West Church Report met Fr. Ioan in his book-lined study at the Faculty of Orthodox Theology to hear about his decades furthering theological inquiry in Romania. The interview took place in English.

What is your current role in the Faculty of Orthodox Theology?

            I am one of a dozen professors and lecturers here. My first responsibility is as Professor for Old Testament Studies, including the Theology of the Old Testament and related secondary disciplines: Biblical Archaeology, Hebrew Biblical Language, and Modern Universal History. My own doctoral thesis was on the theology and language of the Book of the Prophet Hosea. Our faculty is one of 22 within Babeș-Bolyai University—the largest university in Romania—and it is also one of the largest theology faculties in the country. Across the three levels of Bachelor’s, Master’s, and PhD studies, we have 600 to 700 students. At the moment, there are some 150 students in the doctoral study program alone.

That is just students of Orthodox theology?

            Just Orthodox. Babeș-Bolyai University is a special case in Europe, because we have four theological faculties: Orthodox, Roman Catholic, Greek Catholic, and Reformed. Yesterday I was talking with a colleague in the Greek Catholic faculty, who told me they have around 250 students. The Roman Catholic faculty has around 100, as does the Reformed faculty—they specialize in only pedagogics and ecclesiastical music. So, there are approximately 1,000 theology students altogether in the four faculties.

We also have another form of diversity in the religious field. We have a small number of students engaged in Jewish Studies—I also teach a program in that—and our university has an Institute of Turkish and Central-Asian Studies, which has some engagement with Islam. Here in our faculty, we have a special program in international geopolitics and geo-religiosity, where we study Christianity, Islam, and Judaism to understand how to manage international conflicts. We seek to give students competency in conducting interreligious dialogue with a view to finding genuine solutions.

At Babeș-Bolyai University we also have a Center for Biblical Studies organized by biblical scholars from all four theological faculties, as well as an ecumenical body organized in the same way, so we have a proper forum for interconfessional and interreligious dialogue here. In one of my faculty Master’s programs, I have Greek Catholic students, for example, and together we discuss tensions between the Orthodox Church and the Greek Catholic Church. I am not talking merely about the issue of church property rights [Editor’s note: In Transylvania sometimes violent disputes between Greek Catholics and Orthodox have erupted over historical church property in recent decades.] Rather, in the field of education we come together and are open for theological discourse within the unity of Christianity. 

Do many of your students wish to serve as clergy?

            In our Orthodox archdiocese [Vad, Feleac and Cluj] we have some 10-15 parish vacancies per year, but we prepare around 20-25 students. However, we also prepare candidates from Bukovina, Suceava, Botoșani, and Bistrița [areas to the north and east of Cluj], as well as a small number from the Hungarian zone of Transylvania—Harghita and Covasna [Hungarian: Hargita and Kovászna]. This is because we can offer four fields of study: Pastoral Theology, Didactic Theology—for teachers in secondary schools, Social Work Theology, and Sacred Arts, which is for painters and restorers. I have some of our art students’ work here in my office.

Where are the other major faculties of Orthodox theology in Romania?

            In the cities of Bucharest, Iași, and Sibiu [respectively in southeast, northeast, and central Romania]. The Romanian Patriarchate has also organized a theological faculty extension in Italy, because we have a large number of parishes there. [See “How the Romanian Orthodox Diocese of Italy grew to nearly 500 communities in just 16 years,” Orthodox Times, 15 May 2024: https://orthodoxtimes.com/how-the-romanian-orthodox-diocese-of-italy-grew-to-nearly-500-communities-in-just-16-years.] Theology professors from the theological faculties in Bucharest and Iași have organized a similar extension in Chișinău, the capital of the independent Republic of Moldova. Previously, Moldova had no department of theology at a state university, only private study. The Chișinău extension started this year with the support of the Moldovan government. [See “Department of Orthodox Theology in Iași Opens Branch in Moldova,” Orthodox Christianity, 5 October 2023, https://orthochristian.com/156451.html.]

Moldova is an ancient part of Romania which was annexed by the Soviet Union in Stalin’s time. We are brothers—the language spoken there is Romanian—and so we try to develop together in the theological, as well as cultural, field.

Particularly given the ongoing war in Ukraine, how are Romanian Orthodox relations with the Moscow Patriarchate in Moldova?

            Metropolitan Vladimir [of Chișinău and All Moldova, head of the Moscow Patriarchate’s metropolitanate in Moldova] recently affirmed his relations with the Russian church. We are not trying to make Moldovan Orthodox dependent upon the Romanian Patriarchate in a dictatorial way—we try to assist them, but only if assistance is requested. Diplomatic relations are necessary between our two Orthodox churches, and we hope that Moldovan Orthodox theology can become the point of contact for dialogue between the Romanian and Moscow Patriarchates.

Unity in Orthodoxy is a different matter from the political situation shaped by the war: We have unity in theology. In the late 19th century, the great monasteries of Russia developed as theological centers, and Russia produced great theologians such as Georges Florovsky, Pavel Florensky, and Vladimir Solovyev. Many of them lived in exile due to the 1917 Revolution and developed Russian émigré theology in the West. such as John Meyendorff, Alexander Schmemann, Boris Bobrinskoy. This is the unity of our Orthodoxy, which brings together Russians, Poles, Czechs, Romanians, Greeks, and so on: We find contact in this theology, if not the political position of the [Russian] Church. Here too, we are in contact with Moscow—but in a prudent way. In that respect, Orthodox unity is still an ideal, a task before us.

Were you also a student at Babeș-Bolyai University?

            No. I completed my studies in the Communist period. At that time there were six theological seminaries that were the responsibility of the Romanian Orthodox Church, not the state. They operated with the agreement of the state and were under the control of the State Secretariat for Religious Affairs [Romanian title: Secretariatul de Stat pentru Culte]. There were also two  university faculties of theology in Bucharest and Sibiu.

I studied theology at the seminary here in Cluj—situated close to the cathedral downtown—and then the theology faculty in Sibiu, although at that time it was named the University Institute for Theological Studies. While I was a strong high school student—good at mathematics, physics, and chemistry, as well as the humanities—I wanted to study theology.

Did your family encourage your interest in theology?

            My parents had both been imprisoned. After release, they just wanted to get on with their lives. When I said that I wanted to study theology at university, my father said, “No! I haven’t any money,” because he would have had to pay for these studies. However, the archbishop of Cluj at that time, Teofil (Herineanu), supported each student in their studies. He gave 50 percent of each student’s fees, for example, while 40 percent was provided by monasteries, where we volunteered our labor in the summer months. Our families only had to pay for student accommodation.

Did your parents encourage you spiritually, such as by taking you to church as a child?

            Yes, but vocation does not have a precise definition or explanation. A theological or artistic vocation is a special feeling within us which emerges as a force, our greatest desire to realize something. We understood the difficulty of our path in the Communist period only after 1989, when we were able to understand the diabolic source of the state control that tried to force the church to change its activity. During harvest time, for example, churches had to hold liturgies early in the morning so that they were over in time for people to go into the fields and fulfill the production quotas demanded by the state authorities. Here, a priest had to be a most diplomatic person, supporting the state’s requirements while continuing worship services and upholding other elements of religious life in society. It was difficult, but that was also a period when martyrdom was quite real, a model for both priests and faithful.

Did you experience pressure from the Communist authorities when you were in seminary in the 1980s?

            Yes, that was the moment when we understood what strong control by the state meant. You discovered that liberty was absent from some parts of life. (Sighs.) But later, we found liberty and lost responsibility.

Were there restrictions on which students could enter seminary?

            Very much so. It took me three attempts to enter. When I tried, there were only two places available for our archdiocese. Two! This number was established by the State Secretariat for Religious Affairs, which was a special department of the Department of State Security [Securitate secret police agency]. It exerted control over religious institutions.

Were there also limitations on the availability of theological books and materials?

            Yes. There was a general practice in the Communist period: The largest libraries in the country had a secret collection that was not open to ordinary readers. When I was a student, the works of [20th-century émigré Romanian writers] Mircea Eliade and Eugène Ionesco had been published in English, French, and Spanish, but we had no possibility of finding their works because all those books were held in this secret collection. If you wanted to study something you could view it, but not read it just out of casual interest.

Do you think that the persecution suffered by the Romanian Orthodox Church during the Communist period led to any distinctive theological understanding?

            It is so difficult to return to that period and ascertain the nature of the state’s control. Now we use the word “persecution,” but at the time, the church leadership was simply trying to find a proper solution for the survival of church communities. It was a little like that television show, Survivor! [Editor’s note: A reality television series in which contestants are stranded on a desert island and have to compete against one another in a process of elimination in order to win a prize.] However, I can make one comparison: There was not the same diabolic attitude towards the church in Romania as in Soviet Russia. Following an initial Stalinist period, the life of Romanian society entered a period of equilibrium. The authorities did not stop religious activities. They did put up some barriers to religious liberty, and they demolished some churches when they rebuilt the cities. In other places, however, they built new ones. In our archdiocese, for example, the state authorities destroyed a village when they built a hydroelectric dam at Tarnița in 1974, but they also provided the funds to reconstruct the village church elsewhere. This is far from the only such case.

            There was another interesting thing about that period: Christian unity. The Orthodox, Reformed Church and newer Protestant denominations would come together at conferences, and the Catholic Church offered Romanians scholarships to pursue doctoral studies abroad. There was another side to this, however: If you wanted to study in the West, you had to be on good terms with the Communist authorities. While another student was able to travel—perhaps because of his character—I was not permitted to exit Romania.

Another contrast with Soviet Russia appears to have been that monasteries generally remained open.

            Yes. I was born not far from Rohia Monastery, where Nicolae Steinhardt lived as a monk—a Jew who became a Christian in prison [See also East-West Church Report, vol. 32, no. 2 (2024), 3.] While her mother Elena was always anti-clerical, Zoia Ceaușescu [daughter of Romanian Communist dictator Nicolae Ceaușescu] used to visit that monastery during the 1980s, staying for a week at a time.

            In Romania monastic life was a foundation for spirituality and true Christian resistance. Following the revolution of 1989, the great developments in our church came in the monastic field. There are now as many as 46 monasteries in the neighboring diocese of Maramureș and Sătmar, although I am not sure about our own archdiocese. [Editor’s note: According to local Orthodox priest Fr. Viorel Sima, there are approximately 60 monasteries in the Archdiocese of Vad, Feleac and Cluj.] Romanian monasteries have also developed social programs. At the women’s monastery near Florești [approximately 10 miles southwest of Cluj], they have developed a special program for orphans, for example.

Is there continued interest in monastic life today?

            There are two levels to that question. In the current period monastic vocation is at a low level—it is in decline—but the number of believers who go to monasteries each Sunday or on holy days is great. This is because the world is chaotic, and people are trying to find a place for spiritual silence and equilibrium. They find this when they are at a monastery.

We have also seen a lower number of theology students in recent years, but this is in proportion to the number of school-leavers, and therefore not so much of a decrease. The birthrate in Romania has lowered in recent decades.

Do you see differences in attitude among the generation of theology students that has grown up since 1989?

            After the revolution, religion returned as a discipline in the school curriculum. A generation that studied religion in school has grown up going to church with mother and father. But we still face postmodernity, syncretic forms, and an antireligious spirit, as in America. I hope that the power of church wisdom will renew society; that we can become the element of equilibrium in society. Churches and theological institutions have the great responsibility of finding a proper way to communicate faith in this society. While it is not easy, we try to find it.

 
 

ewcr footer logo

PO Box 76741
Washington, DC 20013   
USA

Contact

Home  |  Site Map  |  Site Feedback  |  CONTACT 
Cookies user preferences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Unknown
Joomla
User
Accept
Decline
Joomla
Accept
Decline
Save