Daniel Scarborough Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 2022
320 pp., $30 (paperback), ISBN 978-0299337247

JULIE DEGRAFFENRIED

Readers are likely familiar with the Social Gospel, a Protestant movement that emerged in the late 1800s seeking to establish the Kingdom of God by combatting the many social problems—poverty, economic inequality, etc.—that plagued the modern industrial world. Daniel Scarborough, in his much-anticipated book, draws on its name to describe parish-level, grassroots responses to needs of the local population within the Russian Orthodox Church in the late imperial era, a period when the Russian Empire was racked by famines, wars, and three revolutions. He argues that “the pastoral activism of the parish clergy during this period shifted the focus of the Orthodox devotional practice in Russia toward cooperative social engagement . . . [which] altered the organizational structure of the Orthodox Church” and “established the Church as a source of trust and mutual aid at a time of disruption and crisis” (3).

Using Russian Orthodox Church records from state archives as well as local ecclesiastical archives of two dioceses, Moscow and Tver’, Scarborough’s book primarily focuses on the activities of Orthodox parish clergy as they navigated this tumultuous era with the aid of—and in service of—their parishioners. He terms their “collective efforts to recruit the support and participation of the laity in the Church’s social mission as ‘the pastoral movement’” (7).

In the first four chapters, Scarborough traces the efforts of parish clergy to encourage lay financial support both by and while moving money and resources beyond the Church to the community from the reform era of 1860s to the aftermath of 1905. Since Peter I’s reorganization of the Church in 1721, the state intended parish clergy to supplement the bureaucracy in surveilling and regulating the populace, yet inadequate funding from state and parishioners hampered their ability to educate themselves, perform their duties, and support their families. In the late 1800s, as Church funding dwindled, clergy were granted freedom to form local voluntary associations to support their pastoral work. Priests then used the resources collected by these associations not simply for personal or institutional support but also to address local problems that threatened the very population whose financial support they required. While lacking a developed theological justification for social justice efforts, clergy themselves appear to have understood their efforts to help their parishioners as deeply embedded in Christian tradition (191).

The 1891-2 famine relief campaign revealed the utility of these collaborations, demonstrating the “indispensability of the parish clergy’s social network” in providing local aid to both Church and state (43). In subsequent crises such as the Revolution of 1905 and the Russo-Japanese War, the Holy Synod requested that local clergy respond, and their efforts—via a variety of mutual aid organizations comprised of clergy and laity—proved significant enough to establish parish clergy as authoritative “community organizers,” a useful if anachronistic description (64).

According to Scarborough, “clerical education was a thoroughly cooperative endeavor” (104), both in terms of the evolution of seminaries and parish schools, the subjects of Chapters 3 and 4. The opening of seminaries to non-clerical estates in the 1860s created an opportunity for clergy to advocate seminary as an option for orphans, a venture attractive to lay donors. This partnership became strong enough to repeatedly buck Synodal restrictions on seminaries, culminating in an empire-wide strike and petition movement during 1905 that made permanent curriculum reform and lay admission. While they did not increase the number of laity attending seminary, Scarborough claims that these changes elevated the dignity of clergy, presenting their careers as results of choice or “calling” rather than family obligation (76). When the pastoral movement touted education as a mutual goal, local lay support made possible the steady expansion of parish schools, up to 1917 (94, 103). Parish clergy served not only children but also adults in rural and urban areas via community “readings,” skill training, and entertainment (94-6, 98). Though often disparaged as retrograde tools of state, Scarborough notes that parish schools used the same curriculum as other schools and were particularly important in increasing literacy among women.

A prevailing view among scholars of the prerevolutionary Orthodox Church is that the exclusion of laity in management of its resources, termed “the parish crisis,” led to a loss of legitimacy for parish clergy in the early 1900s. Scarborough challenges this interpretation in Chapter 5, demonstrating that the pastoral movement occurred despite the hierarchy’s failures to reorganize Church governance (116) and argues that the much-maligned parish trusteeship, originally established to support the local church financially and materially, was more responsive to community needs than previously assumed.

Any opportunity for political influence by the pastoral movement in the new constitutional monarchy post-1905 was short-circuited by Church hierarchy, the subject of Chapter 6. The defrocking of several clergy elected to the Duma and the cooperation of the Church hierarchs with the monarchy in manipulation of elections, restriction of religious freedom, and also opposition to educational reform cemented public perception of clergy as state lackeys. As a result, Scarborough contends, a “lasting effect of the clerical experience in the Duma era was an aggravation of the parish clergy’s resentment of the monastic hierarchy” which “fueled a revolt . . . within the Church” (157).

            The fall of the tsarist regime in February 1917 unleashed a “general revolt against all forms of ecclesiastical authority” (159). In Chapter 7, Scarborough explains how the Russian Orthodox Church became the only tsarist-era institution to survive two revolutions of 1917. In response to upheaval, clergy led diocesan congresses composed of clergy and laity to reshape church organization. The 1917-1918 Sobor (or All-Russian Church Council) was the first held in over two centuries. Its first elected prelate of the ROC was the re-established Patriarch Tikhon, and it reorganized the Church‘s structure along conciliar lines that relied upon shared governance, an event the author identifies as the “most enduring legacy” of the pastoral movement (194). Yet these dramatic changes were cut short by the Bolshevik regime and its war on religion.

            This deeply-researched book provides a much-needed perspective on parish-level clergy and their communities. Scarborough presents a dynamic, thoughtful clergy, complicating their motives for establishing mutual aid organizations and their relationship with Church hierarchy. He provides the best investigation of parish-level organizations in print. His selection of Moscow and Tver’ as representative dioceses is effective, as they contained important seminaries and urban and rural parishes. The voices of the Church’s clerics speak clearly throughout, while the voices of parishioners are largely limited to statistics and financial figures. While persuasive, more evidence of the laity’s acknowledgment of the pastoral movement’s “turn” to community work would strengthen the argument.

            The pre-revolutionary Church has generally been characterized as reactionary and out-of-touch, but Scarborough’s work at the diocesan level forces a reconsideration. In fact, his contention that the pastoral movement succeeded in building networks, authority, and trust goes a long way toward explaining resistance to Soviet anti-religious policies. Furthermore, Scarborough’s description of the late imperial era sounds strikingly similar to observations of local clergy and their community initiatives in the 2000s by scholars such as Russian sociologist Sergei Filatov. One wonders what might have been possible with a revived, post-Soviet, Russian pastoral movement had crisis not—once again—intervened. 

Dr. Julie deGraffenried is Associate Professor of History at Baylor University in Waco, Texas.

ewcr footer logo

PO Box 76741
Washington, DC 20013   
USA

Contact

Home  |  Site Map  |  Site Feedback  |  CONTACT 
Cookies user preferences
We use cookies to ensure you to get the best experience on our website. If you decline the use of cookies, this website may not function as expected.
Accept all
Decline all
Unknown
Joomla
User
Accept
Decline
Joomla
Accept
Decline
Save